Describing The Role of the Spectator-Participant

As I mention in my section putting student-to-student communication in context, I am talking about one type of computer use.  In particular, I am describing when students share and read text in a networked computer environment.  Last Spring in a graduate course, I read James Britton’s article “Spectator Role and the Beginnings of Writing," and while much of the article did not apply directly to the computer setting, some of his ideas had large resonances.  This quotation in particular struck me: "as participants we APPLY our value systems, but as spectators we GENERATE AND REFINE the system itself" (Britton 135).

 

Wasn’t a computer environment filled with spectators and participants?  Weren’t our students inhabiting a dual role of spectator and participant at the same time?  My mind began to think of analogies to describe this dual role and place it in contrast to the student’s role in a traditional classroom.  Although not the best analogy, I kept returning to the theatre as the most descriptive comparison.

 

Analogy for the Traditional Classroom

 

Analogy for the Networked Setting

What's the Difference

 

Contents